The grand bargain President Costa’s new MFF negotiating box must strike
What should focus minds in the next EU budget negotiations is not, first and foremost, how much Europe spends between 2028 and 2034. It is the financial firepower Europe builds for the decade ahead.
Europe needs to finance defence, Ukraine, critical infrastructure and technological sovereignty while national budgets are increasingly strained. Yet negotiations remain trapped between the frugals, demanding spending restraint, and the friends of cohesion, defending a credible European budget. There is a way to bridge this divide.
The grand bargain should have three parts: a high and durable ceiling on EU own resources; discipline over programmed expenditure; and a political commitment to authorise new instruments for common European investment.
The distinction is crucial. The EU’s own-resources ceiling sets the revenue capacity available to back its obligations. The lower MFF expenditure ceilings determine what it actually plans to spend. The margin between them is not money to spend tomorrow. It is essential financial backing for future borrowing, subject to proper authorisation and repayment arrangements.
That is what the next negotiating box should protect. Retain at least the Commission’s proposed 1.75 per cent payment ceiling, and rewrite paragraph 131 so that headroom is explicitly preserved for future EU-backed investment, not presented merely as an emergency safeguard. Ask the Commission to assess what additional margin would be needed for a much larger debt stock, including adverse scenarios.
The ambition should be clear: build a system capable, if circumstances demand it, of taking outstanding EU debt from today’s roughly €875bn towards €2tn–€3tn in the 2030s. Those sums would require new political mandates in the future, not just headroom.
But defence is the immediate test. The new negotiating box should already provide for additional EU borrowing authorisations to finance common defence investments. Loans such as SAFE and Catalyst Europe are useful, but Europe also needs common financing for public goods that cannot simply add to national debt.
The machinery already exists. Through successive crises, the Commission has built a Treasury without admitting it. The fiction that common EU borrowing is temporary should end.
Europe must stop negotiating only what it will spend today, and start securing what it can do tomorrow. Budgetary headroom is geopolitical firepower.
Georg Emil Riekeles is Associate Director at the European Policy Centre.
The support the European Policy Centre receives for its ongoing operations, or specifically for its publications, does not constitute an endorsement of their contents, which reflect the views of the author only. Supporters and partners cannot be held responsible for any use that may be made of the information contained therein.
